I was thinking today about determination and perseverance. How do you stick with something when the going gets tough?
I was reading an article yesterday about homeschooling versus institutionalized preschool. There has been a nationwide initiative to have preschool available for all children aged 3 to 5. The motivation for this is to get kids all on the same level and ready for school. This is particularly advantageous for areas with a large non-english speaking population, as it gets the kids immersed in the language before kindergarten so that they don’t fall behind later on. But some studies have shown that small children learn best through supervised play. Essentially, allowing the child to direct his or her activities while the caretaker is available to encourage appropriate activities (i.e. playing with crayons not knives). Interestingly, that is the concept at the preschool here in Italy. The kids just get to play all day. The teachers talk to them a lot, sing songs–basically things to help them develop language skills. The government run version of preschool in the states has set times for everything…time for snack, time for potty, time to color, now time to sing. The children have no choice in the matter. This is the same as all public educational systems in the US. When young people get to college many have a hard time with their new found freedom. They don’t know how to be responsible because they’ve always been told exactly what to do, how to do it, and when to do it.
I have issues with our educational system. Even at its best it makes people fear failure. You can never be creative (or successful) without being willing to take risks. Teaching a child to fear failure goes against everything I believe in. I think we’d all be much happier if we had the “there is no attachment to the outcome” mentality. But that is definitely not the way public schools do things. I’ve always understood that my beliefs weren’t quite aligned with our public school system. So, I always sort of thought that I’d like to homeschool. That is unless I found a viable alternative.
One of the moms in my neighborhood is a teacher. She never really planned to homeschool. But upon moving here, and being an hour bus ride from the school (a school that wasn’t really that great anyway) they decided to homeschool. The motivation was providing a better education than what was locally available, making up for some slack areas from previous public school education, and avoiding the kids having to ride an hour each way to school and back. So, it was situational home schooling, not philosophical. Things were more difficult than anyone had expected. As I’ve written here, there is a tendency to feel isolated when living in a foreign country. You have to try really hard to stay in contact with other Americans, just to have someone to talk to. So, when you are at home all day teaching your two kids, when do you get to interact with other adults? You don’t. And the kids don’t get to interact with other kids. For some personalities this is okay (introverts). The family in question found that it was working alright for the daughter, but the son was really struggling. He is a typical extrovert who thrives in groups–truly needs to be around lots of other kids his age. They were doing organized sports groups three times a week. But it just wasn’t enough. Sometimes a situation gets the best of your ideals.
Seeing this situation I’ve questioned whether I can really homeschool a child or children. Do I really have the patience for that? Alex is not even two, and I already want him out of the house a couple hours a day! But at the same time, I wouldn’t be homeschooling because of a situational issue. I have very strong objections to the US school system. I’ve had to figure things out the hard way. I’ve constantly struggled against that fear of failure that was instilled in me at a very young age. There is a battle inside my mind anytime I try something where I don’t instantly succeed. “Do something else, you are no good at this.” “Just give up!” Perseverance is not my forte.
Interestingly, running has helped me get past that programming. When I was younger (middle school/high school), I was always interested in running. It always looked like fun. But the couple of times I tried it in middle school, I wasn’t very fast and I didn’t have the endurance to do distance. Unfortunately public education isn’t geared towards encouraging kids to try new things. So, I let feelings of intimidation and inadequacy keep me from ever pursuing my interest. Fast forward to a decade or so later. I was working at a YMCA and a coworker encouraged me to come out with the marathon training group. They were going for a 12 mile run. Every bit of logic said “whatever, that’s crazy,” but my coworker said “I think you can do it.” That’s all it took. Having someone believe in me. I went on to train for the full marathon, an exercise in discipline and perseverance if there ever was one! It was something I never thought I could do in a million years. It was something for which I have no natural aptitude. But I did it anyway. It helped me learn that it is possible to see things through even when they are uncomfortable, illogical, and maybe even insane. I can truly do anything I set my mind to.
And here it comes full circle. Even though it will be an immense challenge to homeschool, isn’t that what is truly best for my child? If I can teach him things in his first 10 years that it took me 30 to learn, shouldn’t I do it? If I can set him up to succeed by not fearing failure, by understanding the value of trying, exploring, and being creative, then isn’t it worth it? Shouldn’t I persevere under the uncomfortable, illogical, and insane moments that are all part of raising a child?